Barclay Review Fails the Scottish Hydro Industry

Barclay Review Fails the Scottish Hydro Industry

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: Wednesday August 23. 2017

Barclay Review Fails the Scottish Hydro Industry

The Barclay report into business rates in Scotland has failed to tackle the fundamental problem faced by the hydro industry in Scotland, hydropower leaders claim. Instead of proposing solutions to a crisis in the Renewable Energy system, the Barclay review merely suggests further investigation of the Plant & Machinery Order – key legislation determining Rateable Values for energy sites – offering no prospect of change until 2022.

Adrian Loening, chairman of the British Hydropower Association, said:

“The much-hyped Barclay review does little to challenge the Scottish Government to bring nondomestic rates legislation into the 21st century. After an entire year of consideration, all the report offers are minor amendments and further reviews – all too little, or too late, for the beleaguered hydropower industry in Scotland.”

Martin Foster, Chairman of Alba Energy, representing independent Scottish hydro operators, said:

“For the last five years, the small hydro industry has repeatedly reported and appealed a crisis in methods used to generate rateable values for small hydro – which have now increased by hundreds of percentage points, out of all proportion to the small wind sector. Ken Barclay and his team have had a year to investigate, but have produced little of significance for independent hydropower operators.”

The BHA and Alba have called on the Scottish Government to act quickly to bring non-domestic rates for the hydropower industry into line with that paid by industries of commensurate scale, most particular the wind sector, which may be achieved by a minor clarification of – or amendment to – Plant & Machinery legislation.

Industry representatives also claim they do not want relief, but just fairness. The Barclay review focuses on the implementation of government relief schemes, when what is actually required is a fair system of valuation to bring the non-domestic rates system into the modern era, so that local taxation of industry reflects the complexity of modern business.

For further information contact Simon Hamlyn, CEO of the British Hydropower Association,, 07788 278422

Notes for Editors

  • The British Hydropower Association is the trade membership association representing the interests of the UK hydropower industry
  • Alba Energy is a collective of independent hydro operators in Scotland.
  • The valuation methodology is a devolved matter, prescribed by Scottish Government legislation (Plant & Machinery order).
  • “Small hydro” is here used to define hydro projects that fall within the Feed-in-Tariff scheme, which includes hydro sites of up to 5 megawatts of generating capacity.
  • Feed-in-Tariffs were introduced to pay back the development costs of building hydro schemes, but have been calculated by assessors as simple income.
Previous Post
Investors warn tidal power project risks stalling
Next Post
SEPA takes aim at Scottish Hydropower with huge fee increases

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.